First Internet Bank Customer Reviews
The Bankrate promise
At Bankrate we strive to help you make smarter financial decisions. While we adhere to strict , this post may contain references to products from our partners. Here's an explanation for .
First Internet Bank customer ratings and reviews

NMLS: 424182
4.9
418 ratings
This lender has 1 recent reviews.
99% of customers would recommend this lender.
1 of 1 reviews
The consumer reviews posted on Bankrate.com ("Bankrate") are individual, subjective opinions of reviewers, and not of Bankrate. Bankrate does not endorse any of the opinions expressed by reviewers or any responses to reviews.
Bankrate cannot guarantee or verify the accuracy of the opinions shared by individual reviewers, and reserves the right to reject or remove any review, at any time, for any reason at Bankrate’s sole discretion, including but not limited to those that Bankrate deems inappropriate, fraudulent, invalid, irrelevant, or otherwise outside the parameters of the Bankrate Review Guidelines, the Privacy Policy, or the Terms of Use.
To help serve you with relevant information, the consumer reviews shown below are limited to only those that this advertiser has received during the past 12 months.
Rates and terms of loan honored?
Closed mortgage with this lender?
Closed on time?
Would you recommend this lender?
Rates and terms of loan honored?
Closed mortgage with this lender?
Closed on time?
Would you recommend this lender?
FIB Doesn't know what a trust is.
First Internet Bank paid a nice rate of interest on CD's. I opened two accounts, I am the trustee for the two accounts. They created a personal tax liability for me when they opened both accounts in my name and using my social security number. At the account opening, I gave them the information for both trusts, including the tax ID ##'s. They ignored it at opening, and twice more when I tried to correct the situation. They even told me it was my fault. I have now withdrawn the monies at maturity.
Rates and terms of loan honored?
No
Closed mortgage with this lender?
No
Closed on time?
N/A
Would you recommend this lender?
No
Michael
Tulsa (Nov. 6, 2023)
Rates and terms of loan honored?
No
Closed mortgage with this lender?
No
Closed on time?
N/A
Would you recommend this lender?
No